Exercising but Still Not Getting Stronger? The Top 3 Truths About Building Muscle After Menopause
If you’re exercising regularly, trying to eat healthy, and still wondering why you don’t feel stronger, the answer probably isn’t that you need to work harder. For women over 50, building muscle after menopause comes down to a few basic things that are easy to overlook: giving your muscles enough of a challenge, eating enough protein to support them, and allowing enough recovery for your body to actually adapt.
This week I had two very different conversations with clients about building strength.
One client told me how excited she was that the scale she uses to track body composition showed her muscle mass percentage had increased by 1% since we started working together only six weeks ago. Home scales aren’t perfect measurements of muscle gain, of course, but what stood out to me was what she had been doing consistently during that time. She’s been following the three-day-a-week strength program I developed for her using the equipment she already has at home, and she’s made a conscious effort to eat more protein.
Another client walks daily, hikes, swims, and eats a healthy diet. She started back up with strength training about a month ago, although she had about a week away from it during that time. When we talked this week, she was disappointed because she didn’t feel any stronger yet.
Her frustration made sense. She’s active. She takes good care of herself. She’s putting in effort. So why doesn’t that automatically translate into feeling stronger?
These two experiences are a good reminder of three important truths about building muscle after menopause, especially if you’re already exercising and eating pretty well but still feel like your strength isn’t improving.
Truth #1: Consistently challenging your muscles with resistance training is what builds strength
I often see two different scenarios that frustrate women when they’re trying to get stronger.
The first is the woman who is incredibly consistent. She goes to the same exercise class three times a week, does the same exercises, the same number of repetitions and uses the same size dumbbells month after month. She is definitely exercising, but at some point her body adapts to what she’s asking it to do.
If you’ve been doing the same routine with the same 5-pound dumbbells for months—or years—those weights may no longer be challenging enough to give your muscles a reason to get stronger.
That’s where progressive resistance training comes in. Over time, we gradually increase the challenge. That could mean using a heavier weight, adding a few repetitions, increasing your range of motion, or moving to a more challenging version of the exercise. You don’t need to change everything at once, but your muscles do need a reason to continue adapting.
Then I see the opposite problem...
This woman has a good progressive strength program. She gets to the gym or sets up her workout space at home, warms up, does her three sets of 8–12 reps of squats, lunges, chest presses, rows, and core work, and follows the plan beautifully for a couple of weeks.
Then an appointment pops up on Wednesday morning. Friday’s workout gets skipped because she needs to leave early for a weekend trip. By Monday she’s tired from a busy weekend, so she decides to go for a walk instead. A week or two later she picks the weights back up, gets going again, and before long the cycle repeats.
Missing a workout here and there isn’t the problem. That’s life. But if strength training repeatedly gets pushed aside for weeks at a time, your body never gets enough consistent exposure to the program to make much progress.
So there are really two pieces here: your muscles need enough challenge, and they need that challenge consistently enough for your body to adapt.
Truth #2: More workouts won’t build muscle if you’re not eating enough protein
This is one of the biggest things I see with women over 50. They know how important exercise is for muscle and bone health. So they’re active and follow a resistance training plan, and they eat a generally healthy diet, but when we actually look at how much protein they’re eating, it’s often much less than they realize.
And protein becomes even more important as we get older.
As we age, our bodies don’t use dietary protein as efficiently as they did when we were younger. In simple terms, our muscles become less responsive to the protein we eat, so we generally need a little more protein—and enough of it at each meal—to create the same muscle-building response we once got from a smaller amount.*
There isn’t one perfect protein number for every woman because needs vary based on body size, activity level, health and goals. But for many active women over 50, somewhere around 100–140 grams per day can be a useful range, ideally spread between three or four meals instead of saving most of it for dinner.
Protein is essential because strength training and protein work together. Resistance training gives your muscles the signal that they need to become stronger. During recovery, your body repairs and rebuilds those muscles, and protein provides the amino acids needed to do that work.
That’s why simply adding more workouts won’t necessarily get you the result you want if your body doesn’t have enough of the building blocks it needs.
And this doesn’t mean you need to live on protein shakes or obsess over every gram you eat. It can start with something as simple as looking at each meal and asking, “Where is my protein?”
If you want help figuring out how much protein you need and how to get more into your diet without creating an overcomplicated meal plan, you can download my free guide, The Protein Advantage for Women 50+.
Truth #3: Recovery isn’t being lazy; it’s part of how you build muscle
As a fitness coach, I often get asked, “What else should I be doing?”
I see this a lot in women at the stage of life when they finally have more time to focus on themselves. The kids are out of the house, and now that they’re retired or working less, they have room in the schedule to work out. So they start walking daily, going to Pilates or yoga, taking spin classes, swimming, and making a fantastic effort to improve their health so they can stay strong, active, and healthy as they get older.
Then, when they don’t see the changes they expected, they assume they need to do even more. They add four days of weight training into the mix, tack a barbell class onto yoga, or keep piling more activity onto an already full week. Before long, they’re sore, tired, hungry all the time and wondering why all that exercise doesn’t seem to be helping.
This is where recovery becomes especially important after menopause.
Estrogen plays a role in muscle health, inflammation and the repair and regeneration of muscle tissue. After menopause, when estrogen levels are much lower, we no longer have the same hormonal environment supporting those processes that we had when we were younger.
That doesn’t mean women after menopause can’t build muscle. We absolutely can. But it does mean that recovery deserves more attention, not less.
The workout itself is the stimulus. It tells your body, “I need to be stronger for this.” The actual rebuilding and adaptation happen afterward.
That’s why sleep, adequate nutrition, stress management and rest between harder training sessions are all part of your strength program. If you’re constantly stressing the body without giving it enough time and resources to recover, adding another workout isn’t necessarily going to move you forward faster.
Sometimes when a client asks me, “What else should I be doing?” the answer is actually: nothing else. Let the work you’re already doing have a chance to work.
You can absolutely build muscle after menopause
Menopause doesn’t mean you’re destined to get weaker. And it is absolutely not too late to start building strength.
But the fundamentals matter.
Your muscles need to be challenged enough to adapt. You need to strength train consistently enough to see progress. You need enough protein to support muscle repair and growth. And you need to give your body the recovery time it needs to actually become stronger.
If you’re already putting in a lot of effort but feel like you’re spinning your wheels, you may not need to do more.
You may need to focus more consistently on the few things that matter most.
*Research on age-related “anabolic resistance” shows that older adults often have a reduced muscle protein synthesis response to a given amount of dietary protein, which is one reason higher protein intakes are commonly recommended with age. Bauer, Jürgen et al. “Evidence-based recommendations for optimal dietary protein intake in older people: a position paper from the PROT-AGE Study Group.” Journal of the American Medical Directors Association vol. 14,8 (2013): 542-59. doi:10.1016/j.jamda.2013.05.021
Comments